Shoofly Pie Coffee

Indulgent, rich, and unmistakably Lancaster, Shoofly Pie coffee captures the classic flavor of Pennsylvania Dutch tradition in every cup. This delicious blend features gooey molasses notes with warm vanilla, brown sugar, and a touch of baked crumb topping, creating a smooth, comforting brew inspired by the region’s most iconic dessert. A long-time customer favorite, Shoofly Pie coffee is now available year-round - bringing the taste of Lancaster County’s heritage straight to your kitchen. Product Details Freshly roasted by Lancaster County Coffee Roasters, your local source for artisan small-batch coffee. Made with 100% Arabica coffee beans for a smooth, balanced flavor. Crafted with gourmet flavorings to enhance our premium roasted coffee. Full medium roast highlighting both our coffee and the molasses-brown sugar flavor. Looking for Single Brew Cups? Click here.  Shoofly Pie coffee offers the perfect Lancaster County tradition in every sip. Select your desired bag size and ground or whole bean under "choose an option" below.