Both My Dads Think Your Gay

Bumper Stickers That Make People Go “Huh?” Introducing our boldest, gayest, most grammatically unhinged design yet. This weatherproof sticker or car magnet reads: “both my dads think your gay” — and yes, we know it’s wrong. We made it that way on purpose. It’s chaotic. It’s a funny bumper sticker that hits like a typo tweet you can’t stop thinking about. And it belongs on your bumper, toolbox, water bottle, dorm mini-fridge, mailbox, or your big gay heart. If you're here for grammar, please exit stage left. If you're here to make someone at a red light absolutely spiral, congratulations. You win. Funny Bumper Sticker or Magnet? You Decide. Why does this exist? Because two dads, somewhere, saw your driving and said, “Yeah. That tracks.” We made it loud. We made it proud. We made it just grammatically incorrect enough to make both your English teacher and your aunt's new conservative boyfriend weep. Typos? Absolutely. Intent? Fully loaded. Vibes? Maximum unhinged. Choose vinyl sticker or car magnet — both are weatherproof, judgment-proof, and parent-approved. Especially if your parents are both dudes and have a wicked sense of humor. Premium Weatherproof Sticker for the Unapologetically Online This isn’t some cheap, pixelated nonsense cooked up on a drop-shipping site. This is industrial-grade vinyl, precision die-cut and lovingly abused by our printers right here in the U.S. We drag every sticker through a swamp of sass, sarcasm, and UV-protective laminate so it can survive your back window, a Florida summer, or an Idaho winter. Waterproof? Yup. Fade-resistant? Yes. Worthy of your car, laptop, or busted emotional support Nalgene? Duh. The weatherproof sticker version is perfect for long-term commitment. The car magnet version is removable in case you need to hide it when your uncle comes over. Car Magnet Version: For the Chronically Unhinged but Commitment-Phobic Want the chaos without the commitment? The car magnet edition is here for you, baby. Slap it on your bumper. Take it off when you pick Grandma up from church. Slap it on again before pulling into Whole Foods like a menace. Every funny bumper sticker magnet we sell is thick, durable, and made to endure the heat of both your engine and your unresolved trauma. No peeling. No flopping. No weak magnets. This thing will cling to your car tighter than a kid in a Target aisle asking for a toy. Not Just Funny—Historically Irresponsible Let’s be honest, this might be the first sticker that’s both: A queer rights anthem And a grammatical hate crime We love that for you. Put it next to your “Don’t Honk I’m Facetiming My Cat” sticker. Layer it over your “Horse Denier” magnet. Gift it to your bisexual coworker. Confuse everyone at the dog park. This is the vinyl sticker version of a Tumblr post your therapist would warn you about. If it doesn’t get at least one person to yell “What the hell does that mean?!” at a gas station, we will personally cry. Need-to-Know Specs: Size: 8.5” x 2.5” Material: Premium weatherproof vinyl or thick removable magnet Finish: Matte for that sleek, “I know what I’m doing” energy Printing: In-house, lovingly chaotic Shipping: Free U.S. shipping on all orders Designed and shipped by real life weirdos Collectible Unhinged Vibes This isn’t just a funny bumper sticker, it’s part of the Frog Mustard legacy. Pair it with our other bestsellers like: “Don’t Hit Me My Piss Jugs Are Full” “Horse Denier (They Are Not Real)” “I Eat Copper Cables (Nature’s Licorice™)” “I Piss Red I Shit White I Bleed Blue” Together they form the Infinity Stones of “what the hell is wrong with you” energy. FAQ Is this bumper sticker actually weatherproof? Yes. Whether you’re going through a car wash, a snowstorm, or just a heated conversation with your neighbor, this weatherproof sticker can handle it all. Same goes for the car magnet version. Will people know it’s a joke? If they don’t, even better. But yes—this is a funny bumper sticker designed to be satirical, confusing, and wildly irreverent. The typo is 100% on purpose. We even debated adding more typos. Can I use the magnet on any part of my car? Most modern bumpers are plastic, so we recommend placing the car magnet on a metal surface like the trunk, hatch, or side panels. It clings hard, but peels off clean. Shop All Follow us on Instagram